Generation of Error Message Containing Sensitive Information in snipe/snipe-it

Valid

Reported on

Feb 11th 2022


Description

An attacker can enumerate users through the response time in the password reset page. When you visit the password reset page, you will be provided with the option to enter your email address. Let's use two different emails, one will be a valid address, and another will be an invalid one.

When you enter the first email address and submit the form, you will get a HTTP response within a certain period of time. Let’s suppose this is 5 seconds.

Now, when you enter the second email address and submit the form, you will get a HTTP response within a certain period of time, which is always less than the time taken by the first email address. Let's suppose this is 2 seconds.

Cause

This behavior is shown, because the backend server possibly performs the following actions:

  • Check whether the email address exists in the database,
  • If it doesn’t exist, then throw a response immediately.
  • If it exists, perform further processing, to send a reset email, possibly a SMTP request, then throw a response.

Actually, this is the behavior of the majority of the applications, however in case of this application, the response time varies every time, i.e. the process is happening one after the other instead of doing the email sending part in the background.

By analyzing this behavior, an attacker can easily determine which email addresses exist in the database, and which don’t.

Impact

An attacker would be able to increase the probability of success of password brute-forcing attacks against the system, because he/she would be able to figure out which email addresses they need to try their brute-forcing attacks on.

We are processing your report and will contact the snipe/snipe-it team within 24 hours. 4 months ago
We have contacted a member of the snipe/snipe-it team and are waiting to hear back 4 months ago
We have sent a follow up to the snipe/snipe-it team. We will try again in 7 days. 3 months ago
snipe validated this vulnerability 3 months ago
Binit Ghimire has been awarded the disclosure bounty
The fix bounty is now up for grabs
snipe confirmed that a fix has been merged on 178e44 3 months ago
snipe has been awarded the fix bounty
to join this conversation